There is one special trick that occurs, like magic, in cinema. As though emerging in a momentous puff of smoke from the tip of the screenwriter’s magic wand, it materializes at the crossroads of two things; love and the memory of it.

It’s a very special meeting place and a match made in heaven. After all, what’s better than a love story? A story about the memory of love. Like an ice pick to the heart, it penetrates right through the hollow of the chest, leaves its mark and ultimately melts away. But the mark; the injury of it always, always stays and it makes a cold, drenching mess in the heart in doing so.

As avid cinephiles, La La Land’s Damien Chazelle and Portrait of a Lady on Fire (‘Portrait de la Jeune Fille en Feu’)’s Celine Sciamma both recognise this, and as lovers and writers tend to do, they dedicate themselves to it. How lucky we are to be witness to it.

Chazelle tips his hat to the classics,  La La Land (in all its bright, colourful, dancing glory) being a sparkling affectionate ode to classic American cinema. The film is cinematography and colour theory at its best, the emotions, semiotics, symbolism oozing from each of the classic Hollywood settings, character costumes and even in the nature of the city. Colours clash and complement each other in all the correct moments. He’s not afraid to carry this forward through the troughs and crests of the love story. Beginning in colours that almost seem like an advertisement for LA, hope for big bright futures are clear. Changing then to pastels, beautiful galactic skies, even solely black and white, the journey these characters take is a colourful one. Arguably though, the most indulgent and doting work done by Chazelle in this film – one that sets his love story apart – is his use of recurring symbolic and semiotic colours of meaning. Blue lights; creative success and liberty. A red dress and stop light; a wake-up call. A green shared home; jealousy, emotional discord. Every colour scheme is used; complementary, analogous, triadic. All to represent different aspects of their love, lives, careers in all their glory.

Seeing Sebastian in red and Mia in yellow as they clash at the beginning as American film protagonists tend to do combined with a meshed kaleidoscope of colour as they dance in the sky and finally the emancipation and farewell of the closing scene shrouded in blue is enough to induce pure giddiness and anticipation. That is, to those paying attention (which, at the risk of quoting Lady Bird, is exactly what loving cinema really is; paying attention.)

Sebastian and Mia holding hands while suspended in mid-air in the Griffith Observatory
Sebastian and Mia holding hands while suspended in mid-air in the Griffith Observatory

Sciamma does European cinema proud with Portrait. It is a celebration of cinema completely and it couldn’t be clearer how dedicated to her craft that Sciamma is as a director and writer. And a very French endeavour that is indeed. She is so much in one; a feminist theorist, a queer theorist, a theorist of the Other and her film neatly contains it all, and in a purely simplistic setting with a powerful impact at that. Much like La La Land, colour plays a big role here too, thanks to cinematographer Claire Mathon who utilises 4K to intensify the range of colours that hold the intense meaning and symbolism in the film. For the majority of the run-time, Marianne is in red (fire, enrichment, energy), Héloïse is in green (growth, renewal). Complete opposites, yet we know they complement each other. And we know the memory of their love has massive input: Héloïse taking on red while catching fire; purity and rebirth as she swims in the sea and gets fitted for her wedding dress; future Marianne honouring the memory of them by wearing darker green as she teaches her class. On top of this all, a fascinating (and very subtly used) aspect of colour theory in Portrait is not only the symbolic use of colour hues, but of colour saturation and colour value. Like in La La Land, the romance between the two simply cannot begin until one thing happens. Laughter, shared. (Achingly acknowledged with Sciamma‘s purposeful dialogue, “I wasted time.” “I wasted time, too”). Easy to go unnoticed, it’s luckily not lost on us film fans that as soon as the two women become close, become friendly and eventually become lovers, everything just gets brighter. Clearer, sunnier and brighter.

The best part? It’s almost like studying a classic portrait in itself.

Héloïse smiles while posing for Marianne
Héloïse smiles while posing for Marianne

The use of the gaze, too, impacts both films wonderfully. Portrait going so far as to actively allude to Orpheus and Eurydice making the poet’s choice, (“Retourne-Toi”) as an exploration on how the male gaze can kill but also as a form of 18th century “Netflix and chill” (she really said that!) and La La Land nodding to it in its final moments as Mia witnesses Sebastian in his element; though a finish-line he would never have crossed without knowing her. The ultimate emancipation. (A very important point Sciamma made when she said: “I wanted to question what a happy ending is…We have the romantic-comedy philosophy – a frozen image of two people being together – and we also have the tragic ending. And I wanted neither. Why do we believe that eternal possession of somebody means a happy ending? Love educates us about art. Art consoles us from lost love. Our great loves are a condition of our future love”).

A point that has the power to change cinema for the modern viewer entirely.

Mia sees Sebastian playing at his club
Mia sees Sebastian playing at his club
Marianne looks back after Héloïse says "Retourne Toi"
Marianne looks back after Héloïse says “Retourne Toi”

Anyone can write a love story. To write a memory of a love story is to be advanced in storytelling. A language of looks and lines shared between two people suspended in time. This is what makes these films so special.

Watching Celine Sciamma and Damien Chazelle’s films comes with the gorgeous knowledge that they’ve done their homework. They’ve looked back on their respective countries’ legacy in film, read their texts and said “I’ve got it from here”.

Scratch Cinema Podcast: Reviewing the Horrors of Netflix’s Hollywood & Wrapping Up the Finale of Westworld

Scratch Cinema Podcast: Reviewing the Horrors of Netflix’s Hollywood & Wrapping Up the Finale of Westworld

In this episode of the podcast we joke about who would play Elon Musk and Grimes in a movie, review…

SCRATCH CINEMA’S CHILLING COLLECTION: A Cinematic Guide to Halloween and Horror

SCRATCH CINEMA’S CHILLING COLLECTION: A Cinematic Guide to Halloween and Horror

ByCharlotte LittleOctober 26, 202015 min read

Scratch Cinema has put together a personal collection of horrifying and spooky film recommendations, just in time for Halloween. This…

LFF 2020: ‘Nomadland’ is a Soulful Tone Poem of Loss and Hope in the American West

LFF 2020: ‘Nomadland’ is a Soulful Tone Poem of Loss and Hope in the American West

BySam HoweOctober 24, 20206 min read

Nomadland is the story of Fern (Frances McDormand), a widow in her early 60s who has lived almost her entire life…

NIGHTSTREAM 2020: ‘Detention’ is a Tragic Historical Reckoning

NIGHTSTREAM 2020: ‘Detention’ is a Tragic Historical Reckoning

Bydan kinsleyOctober 23, 20203 min read

While horror filmmakers often rely on the imagination to conjure up scares, some need look no further than human history…

SCRATCH CINEMA PODCAST: The Haunting of Bly Manor

SCRATCH CINEMA PODCAST: The Haunting of Bly Manor

ByChase Hutchinson and Quinelle BethelmieOctober 23, 20201 min read

On today’s podcast, hosts Chase & Quinelle talk through all of the Netflix series with special guest Taya. https://open.spotify.com/episode/2FlKh5EohhqCg7In2mE0iy 00:40 – Intro1:47 -…

LFF2020: ‘Possessor’ violently shows the battle for control of a fractured mind

LFF2020: ‘Possessor’ violently shows the battle for control of a fractured mind

BySam HoweOctober 19, 20206 min read

Brandon Cronenberg’s Possessor is the story of an agent working for a deeply secretive organization that uses brain-implant technology to control other…

Load More

Post gallery

Scratch Cinema Podcast: Reviewing the Horrors of Netflix’s Hollywood & Wrapping Up the Finale of Westworld
SCRATCH CINEMA’S CHILLING COLLECTION: A Cinematic Guide to Halloween and Horror
LFF 2020: ‘Nomadland’ is a Soulful Tone Poem of Loss and Hope in the American West
NIGHTSTREAM 2020: ‘Detention’ is a Tragic Historical Reckoning
SCRATCH CINEMA PODCAST: The Haunting of Bly Manor
LFF2020: ‘Possessor’ violently shows the battle for control of a fractured mind
La La Land and Portrait of A Lady on Fire: The Best of American and French Cinema
LFF 2020: ‘Kajillionaire’ is an Offbeat Comedy with Strong Performances
SCRATCH CINEMA PODCAST: Evaluating Evil Eye, Navigating Nocturne, & What’s New To Watch This Weekend
The Haunting of Bly Manor: A Commentary on Love

Dee Heffernan is an aspiring filmmaker who studies Film & Screen Media with Spanish in University College Cork, Ireland.
She likes sweet and devastating films about human identity, romance, family, women and secretly wants to be a cool skateboarder when she grows up.

Dee Heffernan is an aspiring filmmaker who studies Film & Screen Media with Spanish in University College Cork, Ireland. She likes sweet and devastating films about human identity, romance, family, women and secretly wants to be a cool skateboarder when she grows up.